Atlanta DUI Home arrow Resources arrow Blog - DUI In The News
Blog - DUI In The News
Woman sues Police for false DUI arrest after 3 negative DUI tests for alcohol and Drugs
On July 8, 2008, Paulette Bourke sued the City of Gulf Port, Florida and Officer Joshua Stone for arresting her for DUI.  Ms. Bourke had been at a restaurant with her sister where she had two sips from a glass of wine.  She was pulled over by Gulf Port Police for driving under the speed limit, making a wide turn, and driving too close to the curb.  The Officer reportedly smelled alcohol and ordered her out of her car to perform  DUI field sobriety evaluations.  The Officer would not let her wear her eyeglasses which she reported made her very nervous and uncomfortable as she could not see.  The Officer alleged that she failed the field sobriety evaluations.  She was arrested for DUI.  She was handcuffed and transported to the police station where she gave two breath samples on a DUI breath testing machine which registered 0.00.  She was then compelled to submit to a urine test which indicated negative for drug use.  She was arrested for DUI.   The case was later dismissed by prosecutors for a lack of evidence.  Ms. Bourke is seeking compensatory and punitive damages as well as attorney's fees against both the arresting officer and the city.   These situations are not unique to Florida.  Field Sobriety evaluations are standardized nationally and Georgia DUI Police and Metro Atlanta DUI Police make false arrest based on field sobriety evaluations with accuracy ratings from 66% to 77%.   This translates into 1 in 4 false arrests.  We have encounted many clients who were arrested for DUI and tested 0.00 or well under the legal limit.  Don't be fooled by "over the limit, under arrest" slogans.  It is a war on social drinking.  
 
Metro Atlanta DUI Arrest Report June 30-July 6, 2008

The following is an estimate of DUI arrests in selected Metro Atlanta Counties for one week based on publically available records.  The information is only as accurate as the public records from which it is obtained.  

 

 

 Jurisdiction  DUIs Population

Arrests per Population*

Weighted Police Rankings Percent  change from last week
City of Atlanta DUI arrests 49 out of 486,411 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.)  .0001007  5  increase 2%
Gwinnett County DUI arrests 81 out of 757104 (7/2006 U.S.Census Est.).  .0001069  4  decrease 11%
Dekalb County DUI arrests 52 out of 723602 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0000718  7  increase 50%
Fayette County DUI Arrests n/a out of 106671 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .00    n/a
Clayton County DUI Arrests 32 out of 271240 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0001179  3  increase 50%
Henry County DUI Arrests 30 out of 178033 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0001685  2  increase 25%
City of Doraville DUI Arrests 10 out  of 9862 (2000 U.S. Census Est.)  .0010139  1  n/a
City of Roswell DUI Arrests 7 out  of 78,229 (2003 U.S. Census Est).  .0000894  6  n/a
           
.

*Percent under 1000 means a very low risk of DUI arrest per population.  Percent over 2000 means DUI Hot Spot very risky to Drive after Drinking.  If you would like your counties statistics shown please contact us with information on obtaining the public records.

 
Metro Atlanta DUI Arrest Report June 23-29, 2008

The following is an estimate of DUI arrests in selected Metro Atlanta Counties for one week based on publically available records.  The information is only as accurate as the public records from which it is obtained.  

 

 Jurisdiction  DUIs Population

Arrests per Population*

Weighted Police Rankings
City of Atlanta DUI arrests 50 out of 486,411 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.)  .0001027  4
Gwinnett County DUI arrests 91 out of 757104 (7/2006 U.S.Census Est.).  .0001292  3
Dekalb County DUI arrests 26 out of 723602 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0000359  6
Fayette County DUI Arrests 17 out of 106671 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0001593  1
Clayton County DUI Arrests 16  out of 271240 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0000589  5
Henry County DUI Arrests 24 out of 178033 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0001348  2
City of Doraville DUI Arrests n/a  out  of 9862 (2000 U.S. Census Est.)  .00  
City of Roswell DUI Arrests n/a out  of 78,229 (2003 U.S. Census Est).  .00  
         
.

*Percent under 1000 means a very low risk of DUI arrest per population.  Percent over 2000 means DUI Hot Spot very risky to Drive after Drinking.  If you would like your counties statistics shown please contact us with information on obtaining the public records.

 
DUI Arrest Report for the week June 16, 2008 - June 22, 2008

The following is an estimate of DUI arrests in selected Metro Atlanta Counties for one week based on publically available records.  The information is only as accurate as the public records from which it is obtained.  

 

 Jurisdiction  DUIs Population

Arrests per Population*

Weighted Police Rankings
City of Atlanta DUI arrests 32  out of 486,411 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.)  .0000657  6
Gwinnett County DUI arrests 94 out of 57104 (7/2006 U.S.Census Est.).  .0001241  4
Dekalb County DUI arrests 32 out of 723602 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0000442  8
Fayette County DUI Arrests 17 out of 106671 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0001593  3
Clayton County DUI Arrests 26  out of 271240 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0000958  5
Henry County DUI Arrests 36 out of 178033 (7/2006 U.S. Census Est.).  .0002022  2
City of Doraville DUI Arrests 12  out  of 9862 (2000 U.S. Census Est.)  .0012167  1
City of Roswell DUI Arrests 4 out  of 78,229 (2003 U.S. Census Est).  .0000511  7
         
.

*Percent under 1000 means a very low risk of DUI arrest per population.  Percent over 2000 means DUI Hot Spot very risky to Drive after Drinking.  If you would like your counties statistics shown please contact us with information on obtaining the public records.

 
Fourth DUI in 10 years a Felony and additional DUI classes start July 1,st 2008

On July 1st, 2008, Georgia DUI laws will get tougher.  The new Georgia DUI law is designed to teach new DUI offenders an additional lesson and increase jail time and consequences for multiple offenders.   The Georgia General Assembly passed House Bill 336 with very little opposition in 2008 legislative session.  Beginning  on July 1st, 2008,  people who plea to or are convicted of driving DUI will be subject to more jail time, a felony record in some cases, and additional DUI classes.  A fourth DUI in Georgia in ten years will be felony if you are arrested after July 1st 2008.   It doesn't matter where the other DUIs occurred as long as the Fourth one is a Georgia DUI.   Your first two DUI convictions or pleas are regular misdemeanors subject to a year in jail or a $1000 fine.  A third Georgia DUI is a high and aggravated misdemeanors which increases the maximum punishment up to $5,000 and a year in jail generally with limited good time credit  for time served, meaning you are likely to serve day for day.  A new  felony DUI conviction will result in a prison sentence of one to five years but can be probated or suspended by the Judge except for 90 days which is mandatory.   Additionally, the measurement for minimum punishments for 1st, 2nd, and 3rd DUIs will increase from 5 years to 10 years.  This means that if you had a DUI  6 years ago and get a second DUI you will be subject to minimum punishments of 72 hours in jail as opposed to 24 hours and the additional requirements of a 2nd in Five DUI like 30 days community service et cetera. 

The new law will make changes in sentencing for first Georgia DUI offenders.  There will be another requirement after a Georgia DUI Defendant completes the Georgia DUI School which is a 20 hour $280 course.  For a first Georgia DUI conviction, in addition to DUI School, fines of $300, and 40 hours of community service offenders will have to take a clinical evaluation and complete a treatment program.

 

 
Smoking Gun email reveals Intoxilyzer inaccuracies
A Minnesota DUI defense attorney, on Monday, June 9, 2008, released a copy of an incriminating e-mail from a Minnesota BCA toxicologist to Intoxilyzer 5000 manufacturer CMI Inc. of Owensboro, Ky which laid out tested inaccuracies in DUI breath testing machine.

The e-mail, dated Sept. 27, 2006, indicates that the Intoxilyzer "on occasion" printed out different blood-alcohol readings than what it displayed on its screen.  The email also revealed that the amount of air required to provide a breath sample varied depending upon the version of software running the machine and could trigger a false insufficient sample reading which could result in a one year driver's license suspension for refusal to take the test in Georgia.   These CMI, Inc.  Intoxilyzer 5000 are the "state administered" test in Georgia DUI arrests.   

CMI updated the Minnesota version of its Intoxilyzer software in summer 2005. It was first awarded the contract in 1997.

"We performed a variety of tests under different conditions using each version and the results were not the same," wrote toxicologist Pat Pulju in the e-mail to other state and CMI officials.

 
Intox 5000 discriminates against Blacks and Women

At a hearing before the State of Connecticut Department of Motor Vehicles in February of this year, Dr. Michael Hlastala, of the University of Washington, a forensic consulting in human physiology and DUI breath testing and the nature of alcohol in the body, testified that a woman who ingests the exact same amount of alcohol as a man will produce a DUI breath result that exceeds the man's by 5.6 percent.

Dr. Hlastala also testified at the DUI trial that the lung capacity of an African-American male is approximately 3 percent smaller than a Caucasian. "Because of the smaller capacity, an arrestee must expel a greater fraction of his lung capacity, the Intoxilyzer 5000 results are inflated by a factor of 3 percent," Hlastala concluded.

With Atlanta DUI prosecutors aggressively trying DUI's at the 0.08 level and given the inherent variability of deep lung air in successive breath samples of +/- 0.02 as discussed in the Georgia DUI Intox 5000 training manual (2004 Edition) and as evidence by the Georgia statutory over 0.02 sample variance exclusion rule, this could result in margins of error for blacks and women in the 28%-31% range.

Read excerpts from Connecticut Brief by clicking more.

Read more...
 
First Segway DUI in Idaho
The Boiseweekly.com reported the nations first Segway DUI arrest that occurred in Oct 2007.   The situation had both police and prosecuting attorney's scratching their heads.  So they erred on the side of caution and arrested the man for DUI.   The legislature clarified the ambiguity and legislated that the Segway was not a vehicle for purposes of the DUI law.  Remember a Georgia DUI can occur on mopeds, golf carts, bikes, lawnmowers.  DUIs are not just for Cars and Alcohol anymore.  Segways are specifically excluded from the definition of vehicles under the Georgia Code so it appears that Drunk Segwaying is legal in Georgia.  Remember, this is not legal advice merely an unsolicited opinion.  Do not rely on this for purposes of avoiding a Georgia DUI.  
 
Georgia Bulldog Arrested in Alpharetta DUI

University of Georgia Bulldog Clint Boling was arrested for DUI less safe last week after being pulled over for driving erratically on GA. 120 at 1:30 A.M. on May 14, 2008 as reported by the Atlanta Journal Constitution.  UGA Athletics policy requires that a player who is involved in an alcohol related arrest miss 10% of the season.  The arrest will also trigger a review by the UGA's Office of Judicial Programs.  If found guilty of violating the student code, he would be on probation at the university for one year.  Boling told police was not drinking and refused a breath test.  

At 19 years of age, a driver arrested for Georgia DUI will lose his license for a year to six months whether he takes a state administered test or not, so there is no real incentive to blow.  Then DUI legal limit for Georgia drivers under 21 is 0.02 which is not impaired, less safe or drunk by any reasonable standard and represents a zero tolerance standard.  However, without a test the State must still prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a driver is less safe which is difficult unless the driver's alcohol concentration is generally well over 0.12 (the legal limit back in 1980's when cooler heads prevailed).  Less safe is generally evidence by unexplained weaving or an accident, poor performance on field dexterity evaluations, and/or by appearance and demeanor clearly suggestive of impairment.  Metro Atlanta DUI and Alpharetta DUI college students be forewarned!

 
DUI Detection Deceived by Disability

The St. Petersburg Times recently reported about Michael Loui's DUI arrest.  The alleged DUI Driver's eyes were bloodshot.  He claimed he suffered from allergies.  The Officer, a DUI specialist, noted that the Driver's speech was slurred and he was unsteady on his feet.   The Driver called his doctor who told the Officer that the Driver suffered from Muscular Distrophy.   The Officer did not smell alcohol but was sure that the Driver was using or abusing prescription drugs.  He asked the Driver about his medical history.  The Driver indicated that he had a prescription for Vicodin but had not taken any in a few days.  Bingo, the DUI expert would not be fooled.  The Disabled DUI driver was arrested, booked and jailed.  Justice was served or was it injustice? 

What makes this case illuminating is that Michael Loui, who actually does suffer from Muscular Distrophy and was prescribed Vicodin to ease his pain, was not DUI but simply disabled at least according to a state administered urine test.   Officer Michael Jockers, the 17 year veteran DUI Officer, is still incredulous.   He claims that his standardized field sobriety tests  and DUI training don't lie besides he once knew a Cub Scout with Muscular Distrophy.   The DUI officer insists that the Urine test is flawed and must have missed some prescription drug.  

The lesson here is that Georgia DUI and Metro Atlanta DUI police officers believe that anyone that can not perfectly follow their instructions without being told that they are being so judged, are not perfectly healthy and fit, and do not have the dexterity of a tightrope walker (without a pole) or at least a competition gymnist are under the influence to the extent they are less safe of alcohol or when they can't smell alcohol illegal and/or prescription drugs.  Prosecutors routinely charge DUI defendants with DUI drugs when there is absolutely no evidence of drug use or abuse just in case something pops up at trial.   Further, Police Officers are trained to rely on these imprecise DUI field sobriety evaluations to the point of ignoring the obvious and disregarding common sense and logic. 

 
<< Start < Prev 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Next > End >>

Results 141 - 150 of 203

To obtain legal advice, please call (770) 961-5511 or email George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. at firm@georgialawyer.com. George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. is a law firm representing those charged with DUI or driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs. We have been representing DUI Defendants for ten years in the City of Atlanta, Acworth, Alpharetta, Athens, Austell, Avondale Estates, Ball Ground, Barnesville, Big Canoe, Calhoun, Canton, Carnesville, Carrollton, Cedartown, Chatsworth, Chattahooche Hills, Clarkston, College Park, Commerce, Conyers, Covington, Dahlonega, Dallas, Decatur, Doraville, Douglasville, Duluth, Dunwoody, East Point, Fairburn, Forest Park, Forsyth, Fort McPherson, Fort Gillem, Gainesville, Grayson, Griffin, Hampton, Hapeville, Helen, Holly Springs, Johns Creek, Jonesboro, Kennesaw, LaGrange, Lake City, Lawrenceville, Locust Grove, Loganville, Lovejoy, Marietta, McDonough, Morrow, Newnan, Norcross, Palmetto, Peachtree City, Powder Springs, Roswell, Sandy Springs, Senoia, Smyrna, Stockbridge, Stone Mountain, Suwanee, Thomaston, Tucker, Union City, Villa Rica, Winder, Woodstock, and Zebulon and their surrounding counties including Fulton, Clayton, DeKalb, Henry, Fayette, Rockdale, Gwinnett, Cherokee, Forsyth, Coweta, Cobb, Douglas and Spalding. We also represent Defendants upon request outside of the Atlanta area throughout the State of Georgia.

No legal advice should be obtained from the web site alone. George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. is Georgia Professional Corporation authorized to practice law in the State of Georgia only and all information contained in this web site is intended for use for DUI/DWIs occuring in the State of Georgia. Individuals with DUI/DWIs from outside the State of Georgia should contact a licensed attorney in the state of occurrence of their DUI. Copyright © 2010 George C. Creal, Jr. P.C.