Georgia DUI Cases of Note


Duncan v. State, A10A0651, Georgia Court of Appeals, June 28, 2010

Monday, June 28, 2010

DUI, Prescription Drug DUI, Sufficiency of the Evidence, HGN, DRE, Harper Scientific Reliability. Duncan v. State, A10A0651, Georgia Court of Appeals, June 28, 2010. D. Duncan was found guilty by a Coweta County jury of DUI prescription drugs and alcohol in Newnan, Georgia. 

Defendant was stopped for driving with his headlights off (beause they were inoperable but he had after market foglights on) and weaving.  Coweta County Sheriff's Corporal Chris Segrest approached Mr. Duncan red and glassy eyes, resting nystagmus, slight odor of alcohol and cologne.  Mr. Duncan was unsteady on his feet (Mr. Duncan was injured in a motorcycle accident and has metal rods in his legs).  Mr. Duncan submitted to the Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) but refused the walk and turn, one leg stand and a blood test.

 The Court found that there was sufficient evidence for the verdict.  The Court found that the Coweta Corporal performed the HGN in substantial compliance with the scientific procedures in an acceptable manner.  First, the Corporal admitted that Duncan had resting nystagmus which can be an indication of a medical condition that causes nystagmus as opposed to impairment.  Second, he performed HGN with a strobe light on which is contrary to his training and could have affected the HGN test result.  Third, the Corporal conceded that he was trained to perform seven passes for HGN but he only performed two passes.  Despite these errors, the Coweta Corporal testified that he performed HGN in substantial compliance with "how he was trained."  The Court of Appeals held that the trial court was authorized to find that "the officer substantially performed the HGN test in accordance with his training and guidelines."  Resting Nystagmus, strobe lights and insufficient number of passes go to the weight of the evidence only and not its admissibility. So much for the scientific method, HGN has been relegated to realm of the one leg stand and walk and turn as common sense evaluation of physical dexterity.




    No legal advice should be obtained from the web site alone. George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. is Georgia Professional Corporation authorized to practice law in the State of Georgia only and all information contained in this web site is intended for use for DUI/DWIs occurring in the State of Georgia. Individuals with DUI/DWIs from outside the State of Georgia should contact a licensed attorney in the state of occurrence of their DUI. Copyright © 2015 George C. Creal, Jr. P.C.
    Protected by Copyscape Online Plagiarism Checker
    George C. Creal Jr.
    on Google+

    Atlanta Office: 480 John Wesley Dobbs Ave., NE, Unit 190, Atlanta, GA 30312 Phone: (404) 333-0706