Call Now For A Case Evaluation
(404) 333-0706

Call Now For A Case Evaluation
(404) 333-0706

Blog News -

Rehabilitating Jurors Who Express Bias During Jury Selection in Georgia

George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. Trial Lawyers
www.georgecreal.com | 404-333-0706

In Georgia, the sole purpose of voir dire is to ensure that every juror is free from bias and can decide the case solely on the evidence and the law. When a prospective juror expresses bias or favor toward one side, Georgia law strongly disfavors attempts to “rehabilitate” that juror with leading or formulaic questions. Trial judges are expected to err on the side of caution and remove the juror rather than try to save them.

Statutory Framework

In felony cases, OCGA § 15-12-164 requires specific questions on voir dire, including whether the juror has formed an opinion about guilt or innocence, has any prejudice or bias for or against the accused, and whether the juror’s mind is perfectly impartial. If a juror’s answer renders them incompetent, the statute mandates that the juror “shall be set aside for cause.”

Subsection (d) of the same statute goes further: the court must excuse any juror who, from the totality of their answers, is substantially impaired in the ability to be fair and impartial. The juror’s own statement that they can set aside bias and be fair is considered but is not determinative.

Both the State and the defense also have the right to an individual examination of prospective jurors under OCGA § 15-12-133.

The Walls / Kim Line of Cases

The leading decisions on this issue are Walls v. Kim, 250 Ga. App. 259, 549 S.E.2d 797 (2001), and the Georgia Supreme Court’s affirmance in Kim v. Walls, 275 Ga. 177, 563 S.E.2d 847 (2002).

In Walls, the Court of Appeals reversed a verdict after the trial court refused to strike a nurse who worked in the same hospital emergency room as the defendant doctor and expressed that she “probably hoped” the case would come out in his favor. The court sharply criticized the common practice of rehabilitating biased jurors with a loaded “talismanic” question such as:

“After you hear the evidence and my charge on the law, and considering the oath you take as jurors, can you set aside your preconceptions and decide this case solely on the evidence and the law?”

The Court of Appeals held that once a juror has expressed bias, the better practice is to remove the juror. It famously stated that a trial judge “should err on the side of caution by dismissing, rather than trying to rehabilitate, biased jurors,” because the judge’s primary duty is to ensure a fair and impartial jury. No party has a right to any particular juror.

The Georgia Supreme Court affirmed in Kim v. Walls. It held that when a prospective juror has a relationship with a party that is close, subordinate, or otherwise suggests bias, the trial court must do more than rehabilitate the juror with a talismanic question. The court must allow a sufficient inquiry (including questioning by counsel) to evaluate the juror’s ability to be fair. A cursory rehabilitation is inadequate and constitutes an abuse of discretion.

Application in Criminal Cases

The same principles apply in criminal cases. In Ivey v. State, 258 Ga. App. 587, 574 S.E.2d 663 (2002), the Court of Appeals reversed after the trial court improperly rehabilitated a juror who had been the victim of a similar crime and expressed prejudice. The court reiterated that reliance on a talismanic “can you be fair” answer, when the totality of the voir dire shows fixed bias, is improper. The juror should have been excused for cause under OCGA § 15-12-164 and the reasoning of Walls.

Later decisions, including Ashmid v. State, 316 Ga. App. 550, 730 S.E.2d 37 (2012), continue to emphasize that trial judges should err on the side of dismissing questionable jurors rather than attempting to rehabilitate them.

Courtroom scene with the scales of justice and U.S. flags; overlay reads, 'Rehabilitating Jurors Who Express Bias During Jury Selection in Georgia' with the contact 'George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. | 404-333-0706' How to Preserve the Error of Improper Juror Rehabilitation

To preserve the issue for appeal when the trial court improperly rehabilitates (or refuses to strike) a biased juror, defense counsel should follow these steps:

  1. Move to strike for cause as soon as the juror’s bias is clear. State the specific grounds (e.g., fixed opinion, relationship suggesting bias, totality of answers under OCGA § 15-12-164(d)).
  2. Object to any attempt at rehabilitation by talismanic or leading questions. Cite Walls v. Kim, Kim v. Walls, and Ivey v. State.
  3. If the motion is denied, use a peremptory strike to remove the biased juror.
  4. Exhaust all of your peremptory strikes. Make a clear record that you would have used a remaining strike on another objectionable juror if you had not been forced to spend one on the juror who should have been removed for cause.
  5. On appeal, show that an unqualified or biased juror actually sat on the jury. Under current Georgia law, merely having to use a peremptory strike on a juror who should have been struck for cause is no longer treated as automatic or per se reversible error in criminal cases. The defendant must demonstrate that the error resulted in an unqualified juror serving on the jury.

In civil cases the standard remains more protective: if a party is forced to use a peremptory and exhausts all strikes because a juror who should have been excused for cause remained on the panel, harm is often presumed.

Making a clean, contemporaneous record of the juror’s original statements, the court’s rehabilitation questions, and your objections is essential. Without a proper record and exhaustion of peremptories, the issue is frequently waived or deemed harmless.

Practical Takeaways for Defense Counsel

  • If a juror clearly expresses bias, favor, a fixed opinion, or an inability to be impartial, move immediately to strike for cause.
  • Object to any attempt by the court or opposing counsel to rehabilitate the juror with a single leading or talismanic question.
  • Make a clear record of the juror’s original statements and the totality of their answers.
  • Cite Walls v. Kim, Kim v. Walls, Ivey v. State, and OCGA § 15-12-164(d).
  • If the court seats the juror over your objection and you are forced to use a peremptory strike, preserve the issue for appeal (especially if you exhaust your strikes).

Georgia appellate courts have repeatedly made clear that the goal of voir dire is a truly impartial jury, not the retention of jurors who have already shown bias. When in doubt, the safer course is to remove the juror.

Facing a Georgia criminal case and need experienced trial counsel?
Contact George C. Creal, Jr., P.C. Trial Lawyers
404-333-0706 | www.georgecreal.com

Tags:
Posted to: